Target‘s profit fell by around 50% in its fiscal third quarter as it cleared through unwanted inventory and sales slowed heading into the holidays, prompting the company to lower its expectations for retailers’ most important time of year.
The company also said Wednesday it plans to cut up to $3 billion in total costs over the next three years, citing the need to become more efficient after two years of dramatic sales gains. The retailer’s revenue has grown by about 40% during the Covid pandemic.
Target did not specify how it will reach its savings goal, but said it does not have plans for layoffs or a hiring freeze.
Here’s how Target did for the three-month period ended Oct. 29, compared with Refinitiv consensus estimates:
- Earnings per share: $1.54 vs. $2.13 expected
- Revenue: $26.52 billion vs. $26.38 billion expected
The company’s shares were down more than 12% in premarket trading. The stock closed about 4% higher Tuesday after rival Walmart posted a positive earnings report. Target’s shares were down more than 22% this year and its market value was about $83.38 billion.
Target saw sales decline as families contended with higher prices, making trade-offs between what they need and what they want – a potential warning sign for the holiday shopping season. Target Chief Growth Officer Christina Hennington said customers’ price sensitivity intensified during the last two weeks of October.
“It was a precipitous decline and, frankly, we’ve seen those trends in the early part of November as well,” she said on a call with reporters.
The inflation factor
Target echoed many of the same themes as its competitor Walmart. Consumers are feeling strained by higher prices for groceries, housing and other necessities. They are buying fewer full-priced items and holding out for promotions instead. To stretch their dollars, they are choosing smaller items, value packs or the retailers’ own, less-expensive brands.
People are spending less on discretionary merchandise, too. Walmart on Tuesday also spoke of a pullback in spending on apparel, electronics and similar items. But the discounter beat Wall Street’s expectations as it attracted shoppers with its low-priced groceries.
Big bargains have returned across the retail industry after years of lower inventory and out-of-stocks, a dynamic that is also hitting companies’ bottom lines, including Target’s. The company said Wednesday it now plans for a weaker holiday quarter. It expects a low single-digit decline in comparable sales in the three-month period and an operating margin rate around 3%.
Target did not provide an outlook beyond the holiday quarter, but said it expects tough conditions to persist.
“As we look ahead, we expect the challenging environment to linger beyond the holiday season and into 2023,” Chief Financial Officer Michael Fiddelke said on a call with reporters.
The retailer made progress in clearing through much of its excess merchandise. Its inventory was up about 14% year over year compared with 36% in the second quarter and 43% in the first quarter. Yet getting rid of those goods hurt its profits. Target’s net income in the third quarter fell by about half – to $712 million, or $1.54 a share, from $1.49 billion, or $3.04 per share, a year earlier.
It also missed its goal of healthier operating margins in the back half of the year. It had promised an operating margin rate of around 6% when it cut its profit outlook for the second time. In the third quarter, its operating margin rate was 3.9%.
Target had higher-than-expected markdowns, especially in the final weeks of the quarter, Fiddelke said. It also spent more to manage inventory that arrived early as the supply chain backlog eased, he said.
He also said Target is seeing a higher level of shoplifting — which has jumped about 50% year over year. So far this fiscal year, those losses have had a more than $400 million impact on Target’s operating margin. Most of that has come from organized retail theft.
Silver linings
Target’s quarter had bright spots. The company gained market share across all five of its key merchandise categories when looking at the volume of items sold. At stores and on its website, traffic grew by 1.4% and average ticket rose by 1.3% compared with the year-ago quarter. It also had record sales volumes for back-to-school, back-to-college and Halloween.
Comparable sales, which tracks Target sales online and at stores open at least 13 months, rose 2.7% over the year-ago period. That topped Wall Street’s expectations of 2.2% growth, according to StreetAccount.
The company’s own brands, which are typically less expensive than national brands, grew at double the rate of its total business in terms of dollar sales, Hennington said.
Food and beverage was one of Target’s strongest sales categories, with comparable sales growing by low double-digits. Essentials grew in the low single-digits, fueled by sales of pet and health items. Beauty had comparable sales growth in the mid-teens.
On the other hand, sales slowed in other categories – especially home, sporting goods and toys, said Hennington, the chief growth officer.
Costs and Christmas
On a call with reporters, CEO Brian Cornell said Target is still looking for ways to use its scale to become more efficient. For example, it has opened a new kind of delivery hub to sort packages and get online purchases to shoppers more quickly and cheaply.
Fiddelke said the company will continue to invest in its workforce, but said “expense management is critically important.”
“That kind of discipline will ensure we grow in a variety of economic conditions, and set our company apart in the near and long term,” he said.
Target will share more details about its cost-cutting plan at an annual investor day, which is scheduled for March.
Despite the lower guidance, Target still expects eager holiday shoppers, Hennington said. Target has expanded the number of stores with Disney shops and struck new partnerships, such as carrying items from nostalgic toy brand FAO Schwarz.
And, she added, it will have budget-friendly gift items, too – including $3 Christmas ornaments and $5 candle assortments.
