8 Top-drawer Options: Best Cotton Underwear for Men in 2024

You wouldn’t build a house without a solid foundation, would you? Well, the same principle applies to your underwear. Or at least it should.

It’s the unsung hero of your ensemble—playing a pivotal role in not only your comfort but also your confidence and mood. And there’s no better choice than cotton. Soft, breathable, and easy to wash, it’s the ultimate fabric for your family jewels. This is why finding the best cotton underwear for men should be the next step in improving your everyday choices.

To help, I’ve searched high and low for the finest options around for men’s cotton underwear. From briefs to boxers and trunks, you’re going to discover every type of undies worth investing in. Continue reading: your perfect pair awaits.

Key Takeaways

How did I find the best men’s cotton underwear? It certainly wasn’t by chance. I pored over hundreds of customer reviews, wading through the opinions of fellow comfort-seekers to unearth the kings of cradling crotches—including Calvin Klein’s boxer briefs and a moisture-wicking pair from Hanes.

I also rummaged through my own top drawer, ensuring that each option included has been thoroughly (and fairly) tried and tested.

Why it’s great: I’ve been wearing Calvin Klein’s boxer briefs since my late teens, so there was going to be only one winner when it comes to the best 100% cotton underwear for men.

They’re affordable, seriously soft, and have the perfect amount of support (not too tight, nor loose). The functional fly has saved my bacon on many boozy bar trips, while the full rise ensures they sit comfortably at the waist.

Who this is for: If you’re looking for designer underwear that doesn’t break the bank (or your balls), then I’d recommend Calvin Klein’s time and time again. The pure cotton construction of these boxer briefs allows your nether regions to breathe, so it’s a great year-round choice that ensures your deodorant remains in the cabinet.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: I do find the waistband loses some of its elasticity over time. To slow down this process, I’d try to avoid overwashing them by building up my collection and rotating regularly.

Sizes: S–XXL | Material: 100% Cotton | Colors Available: 10+ | Style: Boxer briefs | Care: Machine wash

Why it’s great: For all-day comfort, excellent support, and minimal impact on your bank balance, Hanes’ briefs are a fine choice. Made from 100% cotton and free from itchy tags, they’re designed to wick away sweat (no need for ball powder) and come with a fabric-covered waistband to eliminate pinching and binding.

Who this is for: If you’re looking for breathable underwear that’s seriously soft and free from annoying tags, these are just what the doctor ordered. The tighty whitey design will also please guys who find that boxer briefs ride up too regularly.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: They lack stretch, which might become a problem for the well-endowed chap.

Sizes: S–XXXL | Material: 100% Cotton | Colors Available: 2 | Style: Briefs | Care: Machine wash

Why it’s great: Supportive, breathable, and moisture-wicking, these men’s cotton underwear offer freshness while keeping everything firmly in place. The cotton construction gives them a super soft handle,  and there’s a hint of stretch to make them even more comfortable.

Who this is for: Not only are they budget-friendly, Nautica’s boxer briefs also go beyond the basics by offering a range of bright colors and patterns—making them the ideal option for guys looking to inject some character into their underwear collection.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: These are one of the best cotton underwear for men, but there’s no functional fly, which could be a deal-breaker for some.

Sizes: S–XL | Material: 95% Cotton, 5% Spandex | Colors Available: 10+ | Style: Boxer briefs | Care: Machine wash

Why it’s great: Durable waistband? Tick. Functional fly? Double tick. Tagless label? That’s a full house. These boxer briefs from Natural Feelings have it all. A comfortable companion for your everyday escapes, they’ll provide all-day support (no bagging) and feel ultra-soft against your skin—whether you’re engaged in physical pursuits or sitting at your desk.

Who this is for: The generous size range and soft double-layer 3D pouch ensure they’ll accommodate guys of all sizes.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: The washing instructions for these men’s cotton underwear state they should only be hand washed, which I personally find a little inconvenient. However, after looking through the reviews, many wearers have decided to chuck them in the machine and had no problems. I’d still recommend erring on the side of caution, mind.

Sizes: S–XXXXXL | Material: 95% Cotton, 5% Spandex | Colors Available: 10+ | Style: Boxer briefs | Care: Hand wash

Why it’s great: Step into the court of comfort with Lacoste’s popular trunks—a winning choice that even René Lacoste would applaud (and he knew a thing or two about balls). Made from stretch cotton with a branded elasticated waistband, they serve up a snug fit and some serious styles that are as rewarding as an Alcaraz drop shot.

Who this is for: Like a custom-made court for your assets, these trunks will appeal to guys looking for a snug fit that also provides the flexibility needed for all your daily moves.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: Some reviewers claim that these men’s cotton underwear run small. So, if you’re usually in between sizes, I’d suggest opting for the larger of the two.

Sizes: XS–XXXL | Material: 95% Cotton, 5% Elastane | Colors Available: 10+ | Style: Trunks | Care: Machine wash

Why it’s great: Admittedly before I set out to find the best cotton underwear for men, I wasn’t too familiar with Perry Ellis’ boxer briefs. Now, however, I’ll be recommending them to anyone who’s willing to listen.

Made to move with you (not scrunch up to your sack or strangle your prized possessions), they’re an uber-comfortable choice, free from tags and unnecessary stitching.

Who this is for: Boxer briefs appeal most to guys who want the support of briefs and the coverage of traditional boxers. They’re versatile and suit various body types, making them an excellent all-rounder.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: They tend to lose a bit of support throughout the day but do generally bounce back to their previous shape (and tightness) once they’re washed.

Sizes: S–XXXL | Material: 95% Cotton, 5% Spandex | Colors Available: 10+ | Style: Boxer briefs | Care: Machine wash

Why it’s great: Crafted with the finesse only Mr. Ford can muster, these boxer shorts are as soft as a cashmere-clad cat and finished with the kind of detail that’ll even get your belly button talking. The comfortable grosgrain waistband is complemented with subtle side slits for a secure yet roomy fit. It’s hard to beat these 100% cotton underwear for men.

Who this is for: If you prefer your underwear a little looser (and don’t mind splashing the cash), Tom Ford’s boxer shorts are ideal. I’d liken the fit to a pair of tailored swim shorts.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: At almost $100 for a single pair, these may win over aficionados of opulence, but the steep price tag is a velvet rope that not everyone is ready to cross, even for the best cotton underwear for men.

Sizes: S–XXXL | Material: 100% Cotton | Colors Available: 1 | Style: Boxer shorts | Care: Machine wash

Why it’s great: For classic, loose-fitting boxer shorts, I always turn to Sunspel. The brand has been making them since 1947, and the quality is unmatched. They’re made from pure cotton and finished with double-turned seams that are feldlocked for ultimate smoothness. Better yet, you’ll find a clever panel instead of uncomfortable stitching at the bum.

Who this is for: If you prefer loose-fitting boxers over trunks or briefs, these are a luxurious choice that offers supreme comfort and freedom of movement.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: Even though these are one of the best cotton underwear for men, there’s no support for your privates. If that’s something you definitely require, you’ll need to choose another pair. Perhaps pouch underwear is more your speed.

Sizes: XS–XXL | Material: 100% Cotton | Colors Available: 8 | Style: Boxer shorts | Care: Machine wash

Buying Considerations for The Best Cotton Underwear For Men

Material Composition

When searching for the best cotton underwear for men, the choice of material plays a pivotal role in determining comfort and performance.

Although pure cotton styles ensure excellent breathability and a soft, natural feel against the skin, those seeking a little more stretch may find cotton blends better. Blends incorporating materials like elastane or spandex provide a bit of elasticity, offering a snug fit and improved flexibility.

Fit

Whether you’re a small or big guy, fit is paramount. Look for styles that offer the support you require and pay close attention to details like a well-designed waistband and leg openings—these can contribute significantly to overall comfort.

Style

The best cotton underwear for men comes in many forms. Consider your personal preferences and lifestyle when it comes to design. Choose between different styles like boxers, briefs, trunks, or boxer briefs. Additionally, explore various color options and any extra features like moisture-wicking properties.

How We Chose

In curating this collection of the best cotton underwear for men, I delved into the depths of customer reviews and my own underwear drawer, while scrutinizing each brand’s reputation. I also ensured each pair offered excellent value for money. Only then was I able to identify the standout performers in terms of comfort, durability, and overall satisfaction.

Customer reviews: Real-world testimonials provided insights into aspects like comfort, fit, and durability, helping me identify the best men’s cotton underwear that consistently met or exceeded users’ expectations.

Brand reputation: What’s the word on the street? I looked closely at the standing of each brand, considering factors such as their history, commitment to quality, and consistency in delivering comfortable and durable underwear.

Price: In the name of fairness, I made it a priority to cover a range of price points without compromising on quality. The goal was to cater to various budget constraints, ensuring that comfort and quality remained accessible to everyone.

Personal experience: Where possible, I used my own experiences with wearing men’s cotton underwear to offer an additional layer of assurance.

Why Trust Us?

Billy Webb, a seasoned writer at FashionBeans, has carved out a niche for himself as a trusted expert in the realms of men’s grooming and fashion. Through rigorous product testing and a keen eye for quality, Billy’s recommendations come from a place of deep understanding and experience.

In articles pertaining to shaving soaps, he has showcased his ability to sift through countless products to find those that truly stand out in terms of design, functionality, and comfort. He is equally at home in the scents space, rounding up a number of the best perfumes for women to wear.

When it comes to the best cotton underwear for men, Billy employs the same meticulous approach, prioritizing factors like material quality, craftsmanship, and user comfort. His expertise is not just in identifying trends but in recognizing the timeless qualities that make a product worthwhile.

Final Verdict

In the pursuit of the best cotton underwear for men, the triumvirate of softness, value, and fit reign supreme. Which is why I believe Calvin Klein’s boxer briefs are the cream of the crop. As soft as they are stylish and supportive, they’re an affordable option that will instantly improve your daily rotation and prove an invaluable foundation regardless of your sartorial preferences.