Of all the traditional dress shoes, the monk strap is perhaps the most distinctive. Laceless with an asymmetrical single or double strap, the formal footwear choice is a must-have for gentlemen looking to add a little individuality to their look.
Its history spans back as far as the Middle Ages, when monks favored them over sandals because they provided better protection and durability. They, of course, looked slightly different back then but would eventually evolve to become the version we know, and love, today.
Join me as I round up the best monk strap shoes for men. Here you’ll find an array of options that will suit every budget, occasion, and style.
Key Takeaways
Halfway between an Oxford and a loafer, monk straps are arguably the dressiest of dress shoes, yet more casual options are available, too. I’ve considered every type, poring over ratings, reviews, and style forums to find the best monk strap shoes for men.
From Morjas’ suede offering to Velasca’s contemporary pair, I’m going to present the crème de la crème—the most comfortable, versatile, and stylish designs money can buy.
Why they’re great: An elegant design that looks just as good with a navy suit as it does with gray, these Morjas monks are a work of art. Not too pointy or round, they boast a wonderfully timeless shape cut in a silky smooth suede fabric. When you’re not wearing them with tailoring, they’ll work equally well with selvedge denim and a plethora of top-half options (my favorite is the button-down Oxford).
Who are these for? Whether these will be your first pair of monk strap shoes or your third, they’re going to appeal to everyone. Classic, classy, and easy to style, they can be dressed up or down and can lend themselves to just about any occasion.
Flaws but not deal-breakers: The leather soles can feel a little slippy, especially in wet weather. That doesn’t stop them from being the best monk strap shoes for men, mind.
Material: 100% Leather | Sole Material: 100% Leather | Sizes Available: 5.5–13.5 | Colors Available: 5
Why they’re great: Apart from being super affordable, these Bruno Marc monk strap shoes are comfortable, versatile, and smart. Featuring a double-buckle design and a soft latex cushioned footbed, they’ll be your go-to for office days, weddings, and everything in between. The durable rubber outsole and wooden stacked heel ensure your feet stay firmly on the ground.
Who are these for? A great alternative to your Derbies or boots, these are a wallet-friendly option that are ideal for a last-minute or one-off event. If you don’t wear shoes often but still want a pair you can rely on, I think you’ll struggle to find better.
Flaws but not deal-breakers: They do have that cheap fake leather smell, though it does fade after a short while.
Material: 100% PU | Sole Material: PU/Rubber | Sizes Available: 6.5–13 | Colors Available: 3
Why they’re great: When looking for the best monk strap shoes for men on Amazon, La Milano’s pair reigned supreme. Reviewers gave them top marks for comfort, appearance, and quality, while there was plenty of positive feedback on fit and value for money, too. I love the memory foam insoles and how they’re versatile enough to wear with suits and smart casual wear.
Who are these for? An excellent all-rounder, these will become a reliable addition to your footwear rotation. Easy on the wallet and eye, they’re a must-have for anyone looking for affordable monk strap shoes that are both comfortable and stylish.
Flaws but not deal-breakers: I did notice several guys complain that they scuff quite easily.
Material: 100% Leather | Sole Material: Leather/Rubber | Sizes Available: 7-13 | Colors Available: 2
Why they’re great: There’s something about the single strap that gives these monks a retro vibe that, at the same time, feels modern and cool. Made using full-grain leather and Goodyear-welted construction, they’re just as tough as they are handsome—looking the part with everything from double-breasted suits to dark denim and button-down shirts.
Who are these for? Slightly more streamlined than double strap designs, these will give your outfits a touch of timeless charm whether you’re a banker or bar attendant. They’re versatile enough to wear with a range of garments but look best when dressed up.
Flaws but not deal-breakers: Quality doesn’t come cheap. Though fairly priced, these monk strap shoes might be a little expensive for those working with a tight budget.
Material: 100% Leather | Sole Material: 50% Leather, 50% Rubber | Sizes Available: 8.5–13 | Colors Available: 2
Why they’re great: A relaxed take on a formal favorite, Velasca’s Abbonà a monk strap shoes feature buffed suede uppers and soft natural rubber soles that are chunkier than average. The apron-toe stitching gives them plenty of character, and the adjustable buckled straps ensure that they remain a classic.
Who are these for? Ideal for every day, this pair can be worn with tailoring but will look just as good with jeans. They’re definitely different from many of the other best monk strap shoes for men, so I think they’ll appeal most to guys looking to make a strong impression.
Flaws but not deal-breakers: Suede often needs more care and attention than leather, making these better suited to warmer, or at least drier, weather.
Material: 100% Suede | Sole Material: 100% Rubber | Sizes Available: 5–14 | Colors Available: 2
Why they’re great: As comfy as sneakers thanks to the OrthoLite insole and impressive arch support, Gordon Rush’s monk straps are made from quality leather with a little rubber on the bottom to help with grip. Suitable for long days standing and plenty of walking, they’re a five-star style that’ll pair with your favorite formalwear.
Who are these for? If you’re after some brown shoes to wear with a navy suit or something more comfortable than your unforgiving Oxfords, these monk strap shoes tick a lot of boxes. It helps that they’re reasonably priced, too.
Flaws but not deal-breakers: The narrow(ish) toe might be a problem for men with particularly wide feet.
Material: 100% Leather | Sole Material: Leather/Rubber | Sizes Available: 7–13 | Colors Available: 2
Why they’re great: As classic as they come, the Amalfi from
Who are these for? A dressy option that works with a variety of suit styles, they’re great for guys looking for a new smart shoe. Thanks to the premium materials and quality construction, these monk strap shoes will become a mainstay in your everyday wardrobe.
Flaws but not deal-breakers: Because there’s no rubber on the soles, you may find them a touch slippy on certain surfaces.
Material: 100% Leather | Sole Material: 100% Leather | Sizes Available: 7–13 | Colors Available: 2
Buying Considerations for The Best Monk Strap Shoes For Men
Material
The best monk strap shoes are made from high-quality leather or suede. These materials ensure the utmost durability and comfort. Leather can be worn year-round, whereas suede is generally better for the warmer months.
Comfort
Ensure that your shoes offer a good fit with adjustable straps that don’t pinch or feel too tight. For additional comfort, look out for features such as cushioned insoles. You may also require arch support.
Versatility
Though considered a formal shoe, monk straps are available in multiple styles with varying levels of smartness. Classic, sleek designs are best for the most formal occasions;Â you should consider more casual versions if you want to be able to dress them down.
How We Chose
To find the top monk strap shoes for men, I’ve spent the past few weeks scouring social feeds, online communities, and customer reviews before drawing up a shortlist of 30 designs.
To narrow the options down to the standout styles you find in this article, I judged each pair on the following criteria:
Size range: Ensuring a wide size range was key in determining the best men’s monk strap shoes. I looked for brands that offered a comprehensive selection of sizes to accommodate different foot shapes and widths.
Price: I compared prices across various brands and models, considering the materials used, craftsmanship, and overall value for money. All budgets were taken into account.
Style: I evaluated each design based on its aesthetic appeal, versatility, and special detailing. The goal was to include the best monk strap shoes that could be worn for a variety of occasions.
Customer feedback: I delved into customer reviews and ratings, paying close attention to feedback on comfort, fit, durability, and overall satisfaction. Shoes with consistently high ratings and positive testimonials were prioritized, as they indicate a reliable and well-loved product.
Brand reputation: Established brands with a history of producing high-quality footwear were given special consideration, though I also looked at newcomers making the most noise. I researched each brand’s reputation, looking at its track record for a quality product, customer service, and ethical practices.
Why Trust Us?
Billy Webb is a seasoned menswear expert and self-proclaimed footwear fanatic, dedicated to bringing the very best products to his readers, from slippers with support to the most comfortable loafers.
Our go-to guy for all things men’s style, Billy began his footwear journey long before his graduation as a journalist in 2012. Having worked in various shoe stores throughout his late teens and early twenties, he developed a keen eye for quality craftsmanship and design, while gaining invaluable insights into what makes a great pair of shoes, from the materials used to the fit and finish.
Today, he leverages his extensive background to guide his audience in making informed footwear choices. His in-depth reviews and expert advice have made him a trusted voice in the fashion community, particularly when it comes to finding the best monk strap shoes for men.
Whether you’re looking for a seasonal upgrade or something special for an upcoming event, you can rest assured that Billy’s recommendations are backed by years of experience and a genuine passion for exceptional footwear.
Final Verdict
When it comes to the best monk strap shoes for men, Morjas is my go-to. The brand’s classic double-buckle design is a timelessly elegant option that’ll take you from family weddings and parties to business events and after-work drinks. They’re as comfortable as they are stylish, and you can wear them with your favorite suit or keep them casual with jeans and an Oxford shirt.
FAQ
-
-
Of course. Known for their distinctive buckle closure, monk strap shoes are a timeless choice that never fall out of favor.
-
Monk strap shoes are versatile and can be worn in various settings, from formal to semi-casual occasions, depending on the particular style. They’re a great option for office days, weddings, and dinner dates.
-
The best men’s monk strap shoes are comfortable, especially when they’re crafted from high-quality materials and properly fitted. The absence of laces allows for a more uniform pressure distribution across the foot, and the adjustable straps offer a customized fit.
-
